María Corina, and a unified theory of rationed repression

Maria-Corina-Machado-AN-prohibida-1Tomorrow, opposition leader María Corina Machado will go to the National Prosecutor’s Office to be indicted as an alleged conspirator in a plot to assassinate the President. Hefty charges that, if proven, carry the maximum penalty of 28 years in prison. In any other country, the “if proven” part of this sentence would be the most important. In Venezuela, proof is completely irrelevant.

Writing this piece was daunting, not because information is missing, but because it has become increasingly difficult to make sense of it. Political persecution in Maduro’s Venezuela is difficult to describe, and that’s exactly the way the government wants it.

Take the build-up to tomorrow’s summons. Many will remember the asinine press conference, broadcast on national television last June, when the “High Command of the Bolivarian Revolution” unveiled a ludicrous Presidential assassination plot based on bogus emails linked with construction paper arrows. Late-night TV host Luis Chataing paid dearly with his job for this much more illustrative recounting of the story.

Back in June, María Corina was subpoenaed as a star witness to this conspiracy, and summoned to the National Prosecutor´s offices for a deposition. What followed were weeks of State-sponsored intimidation tactics joined by a veritable circus of speculation that she would be arrested on site, accompanied by an equally impressive outpouring of high-level international support.

María Corina spent 8 hours in the judge’s chambers, and left the interview without having been asked even a single question regarding an assassination plot of any sort. Google certified the emails as forgeries. The ousted Diputada went back to her daily business of organizing civil society through town-hall meetings and building a coalition in support of the National Citizen’s Congress.

And just like that, the voraciously over-publicized story of an alleged President-Killer-Who-Threatens-To-End-The-Bolivarian-Revolution-And-Ruin-Venezuela-Forever … receded into obscurity, never to be mentioned again.

Fast-forward five months. On the morning of November 26th, María Corina demanded the resignation of the National Electoral Council directors who are open chavista loyalists, and who are bidding for renewed appointments to their office. Hours later, agents of the state security police (SEBIN) showed up at her private home, and served her a summons to appear before the National Prosecutor, except not as a witness, but as an indicted suspect in the same far-fetched assassination plot.

This latest attack on Machado is the latest in a long list of targeted and systematic harassment. She was accused of terrorism for whistleblowing the government’s negligence in the Amuay refinery explosion of 2012. She was kicked in the face by a chavista colleague during a parliamentary session last year. She was stripped of her legislative seat for denouncing human rights violations before the OAS in March. She has been barred from leaving the country for never-quite-specified reasons. And now, she’s being charged with conspiring to assassinate Maduro in the absence of minimally credible evidence.

Needless to say, the due process violations are too many to count. And the accusations get less credible with each notch on the belt.

So, why is the government doing this? What can it gain from these obviously egregious affronts to constitutional order, and, in the case of María Corina, from victimizing an internationally recognized figure whose groundless detention will surely rouse an onslaught of regional condemnation?

Well, for one, it succeeds in generating “persecution fatigue.”

The strategy is to chip away at the morale of dissidents, who grow weary after each crisis results in an “anticlimactic” outcome. It would be the authoritarian version of “crying wolf,” except in this case, the alarm is not false: it achieves its objective of rendering oppression commonplace.

Secondly, this persistent game of carefully parceled repression gives the regime a laboratory of sorts, to test the limits of publicly acceptable impunity.

With each new human rights violation – cases like the murder of Bassil Da Costa and Robert Redman by State police, the ousting of several Members of Parliament from elected office, the jailing of Leopoldo López and two elected mayors, the political imprisonment of Jugde Afiuni and Simonovis – all the other ones fade distantly into a muddled notion of “qué bolas este gobierno.”

Maduro’s government sucks at governing. But it gets away with cloaking its dictatorial practices behind a guise of shoddy administration because it understands timing, and thrives on hyperbole. It operates in the realm of the sporadic and the absurd just enough to make their next desperate move completely undecipherable.

Much in the same way that the Venezuelan regime has mastered the art of rationing basic staples just enough as to elicit a tolerable resignation from its people, so has it mastered the art of rationing political persecution to remain thiiiiiiiis bit shy of becoming a dictatorship in the eyes of the international community. All year they’ve been cautiously dialling up cruel repression: obvious enough to send a message to those who dare to openly dissent, yet comfortingly spaced out for those who conveniently need to see it as legitimate.

Maduro’s go-to response to mounting discontent has been repression. Repression was his answer to this year´s nationwide protest movement. Repression and torture allowed him time to devise a strategy to face a growing governance crisis. Repression was duly silenced with petro-bought complicity and costly, Security Council-worthy lobbyists. Repression was a messy means to a submissive end. Repression did the job.

But what worries me about this latest iteration of that strategy is that María Corina’s summons have received almost no attention in the state propaganda apparatus. Diosdado didn’t even mention it during his must-watch weekly political persecution TV show. It’s a far cry from last June’s Magnicidepalooza.

So if its not a PR tactic to distract from our deteriorating quality of life, or to further silence dissidence, then it has to be personal. The government wants to neutralize María Corina Machado.

Except they already have. She is currently barred from leaving the country, and a ban from political office is just a signature away. Why go through the dirty business of jailing her when you can elegantly write her off with half the political cost?

María Corina is a polarizing figure, even within the opposition. Say about her what you will, it is undeniable that the government sees her as a threat. They would not go through the motions of detaining her if this were not the case.

The fact that they do it in a deliberately haphazard, purposefully incredible way, does not detract from the seriousness of what she, and all Venezuelans are facing. In fact, it only underscores the point further: we live in a dictatorship, and it will stop at nothing to convince you that we don’t.

39 thoughts on “María Corina, and a unified theory of rationed repression

  1. One has to wonder what MC has to gain by turning herself in to a judicially bereft regime. Exile seems far more attractive….Perhaps the the Bushes have a place for her to stay.


  2. “The strategy is to chip away at the morale of dissidents, who grow weary after each crisis results in an “anticlimactic” outcome.”

    That struck home.
    15 years of bullshit would wear anyone out.

    Most of us are just trying to survive these days.


  3. “The fact that they do it in a deliberately disordered, purposefully incredible way…” You can’t have it be deliberate and disordered and purposeful. It’s either purposeful and deliberate or disordered. I think you’re giving the Chavistas way too much credit. Truth is, they don’t have a clue and don’t care whether what they do makes sense or not. The mistake is to try to make sense of it all, which results in the above-quotation.


  4. The purpose is to distract and to incite. The U.S. and others will react, giving them the “us vs them” rhetorical cover that they need. Now if he can just get some bread to go with these circuses.


  5. Since 2001 the Vzlan government has been approaching dictatorship status as in Zeno’s dichotomy paradox: consistently getting closer but never quite there yet.

    Maria Corina is, unfortunately, a divisive figure in the opposition. So is Leopoldo. The government is forcing the opposition into a dilemma where the only allowed way to fight the government is through elections. And, oh boy, they’ve been incredibly successful at this. Countless members of the opposition have blamed #lasalida for the guarimbas and even the deaths in the protests. Ramon Guillermo Aveledo, who’s not nearly as mediagenic or as known internationally as MCM, has been happy to stay in the MUD as their “coordinador internacional”. Any space they can remove MCM and Leopoldo from, is a space someone else in the opposition will be happy to take.


  6. Well said. The Chavez regime had petrodollars and an articulate, if for many of us, utterly strange, English-speaking unofficial official spokesperson, to assure the world all of these kinds of things were normal and proportional measures, adopted in any functioning democracy. Incredibly, some people bought it. Or were satisfied there was sufficient doubt to let it go. Today, with the petrodollars almost nowhere to be seen and the utterly strange but articulate English speaking spokesperson all but vanished, hopefully there will be more willingness in the region to speak out about this sort of thing. Kudos here for speaking out.


  7. Possibly they need to persecute Maria Corina Machado in order to appeal to a constituency within the PSUV: “Maduro may be destroying the economy and generally screwing things up, but at least he’s taking down Machado.”


  8. emi, pls reduce your inserted photo to allow for more dropped text to the right of it. At the moment, the initial read is squashed.


  9. “Secondly, this persistent game of carefully parceled repression gives the regime a laboratory of sorts, to test the limits of publicly acceptable impunity.”

    Well, I think this question has been answered internally in Venezuela long ago…Lopez jailed, persecution of protestors, rampant inflation, scarcity of virtually everything, parallel market at 25x the official rate, etc.,etc. Where is the mass dissention??? The captive audience of the government consists of a largely uneducated, poor population ripe for exploiting. Not much different than some other South/Central American countries where other dictatorial regimes oppress the population and enrich themselves by doing so. Only if and when the masses no longer get the government teat of handouts is there any chance of serious discontent and possible demonstrations over what is happening.The international community will continue to ignore the problems as long as there is passive acceptance by the general population. Where is the outrage over 35-40 very suspicious deaths at Urbina????? In any other civilized country there would be an uproar. Most Venezuelans passively accept bullshit explanations from the government regarding anything and everything.


  10. Speaking of bullshit…..this is the attitude of the USA regarding bullshit….from Veneconomia today.

    Venezuelan surgeon who joked about having explosives in his carry-on
    while waiting to board an Avianca flight in Miami’s International Airport was ordered to pay a $89,000 fine to reimburse the delays caused to five air carriers at that airport, informed a court’s source on Tuesday. Manuel Alberto Alvarado (60) who was detained last October and is currently free on bail, originally faced criminal charges that were later dropped.


  11. María Corina Machado is, among the most visible people in the opposition, the only one that proposes capitalism as the solution to the wreck caused by socialism (what a shocker, no?). I commend her for doing this in a country where everyone is on the left, from AD, UNT, most journos, Capriles, the MUD janitor and pretty much everybody else who think wealth is soplar y hacer botellas.

    Maybe the above is a big factor in the entire absurd scheme.


    • Good point. Muchado and Lopez do not differ from the government in degree but in kind. They are not saying the government has erred but, rather, the emperor has no clothes.

      I also think it possible that the repression may be less a Machiavellian stratagem and more of a holy crusade. I suspect there are many true believers for whom the march of socialism is equivalent to the evolution of mankind from a base existence to a noble one. For such a person Muchado, Lopez, et al. are evil, and evil must be opposed by any and all means. Their treatment is not a necessity but a matter of visceral hatred. Lesser demons can be tolerated for the time being. They will either fade to irrelevance, be co-opted, or, if persistent, be dealt with later.


  12. Very scary. She can be jailed like Leopoldo Lopez with no chance of being released. Everyone is scared of the GNB. The government will get rid of their opponents one by one. The time for talking is over but what can anyone do?


  13. International financial and political pressure will be the only way to free MCM if she is jailed. A few top Cuban and Venezuelan officials leaving their jobs would be helpful.

    Pray for MCM.


  14. Bueno, ella le cantó al muerto una de las verdades que más le ha dolido a los chaburros, lo dejó a los ojos de Venezuela como un ladrón cuando dijo “Expropiar sin pagar la compensación justa es ROBAR.” El imbécil de mierda se quedó tan ponchado que lo único que atinó a balbucear en ese momento fué “¡No te oigo!” Y de inmediato empezó a tratar de manosearse el ego al que le habían metido una patada por las bolas con algo como “¡Eres demasiado mínima e insignificante para que yo te preste atención!”


Comments are closed.